All NACC News

NACC Executive Director Kim Dvorchak pens letter to the editor defending ICWA

Wednesday January 12, 2022

George F. Will’s Jan. 6 op-ed on the Indian Child Welfare Act sidestepped important facts and used misleading storytelling to argue against this critical law.

Mr. Will’s tragic stories falsely imply increased danger to children placed with their parents or tribal kin. Unfortunately, children of all backgrounds experience harm inside and outside foster care. He suggested Brackeen v. Haaland hinges on safety. This case is an appeal of adoption decisions, not safety determinations.

Mr. Will protested “identity politics” while omitting the crux of the legal debate: The ICWA is a political classification, not a racial one. Tribal sovereignty must be respected as a means of self-determination for Native people to have a say in what happens to their children and families.

The question before the court is one of tribal sovereignty and cultural identity in healthy child development. The child welfare system disproportionately impacts Native American children, placing them in foster care at rates more than two times higher than their proportion of the population. As Canada recently recognized, many family separations are unnecessary. Cases from Pima County, Ariz., in which tribes are actively engaged have shown that children have better results under the ICWA.

The ICWA is gold-standard practice because it guards against unnecessary government intrusion, protects family relationships, and emphasizes familial and cultural identity. The Supreme Court should recognize the ICWA as a vital tool to address ongoing injustices against Native and non-Native children alike.

Kim Dvorchak, Denver

Kim’s letter was published in the Washington Post on January 11, 2022

Recent NACC News

All News

  • February 2024 Policy Updates

    February 1, 2024

    Counsel for Kids Lived Experience expert Rebekka Behr explained at a Ways and Means Committee hearing that getting an attorney helped her get a drivers license, reconnect with her family, & navigate...

  • NACC is Hiring

    February 1, 2024

    Join team NACC! Help us promote excellence, build community, and advance justice. NACC is hiring for two positions. See each position for job description and application instructions: National Law School...

  • February Organizational Membership Sale

    February 1, 2024

    The 25% Off Organizational Membership Sale is on now through February! Renew or upgrade at a discounted rate and receive 12 months added to your membership expiration date. Secure the...